A Hayes Family Thanksgiving: I Visited Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums

Part 1 of 2 

The home at Spiegel Grove belonging to Rutherford B. Hayes is pictured. The portrait seen of the late president is available from the Library of Congress.

By Anna Krejci

Thanksgiving became a national holiday during the Civil War. After the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863, the future outcome seemed like the Union Army would win. The holiday, which was celebrated among states prior to then, was proclaimed a national event by President Abraham Lincoln the same year.  I can imagine how thankful the nation was after fighting ended in 1865. When I celebrate Thanksgiving every year, I anticipate eating a generous, rich meal and being surrounded by family. I can imagine the reality for the Civil War soldiers whose camp meals must have been much less extravagant and easy to transport by necessity.

The country’s 19th president was a man from Ohio and a Civil War veteran for the Union Army. I traveled to Fremont, Ohio to visit Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums at Spiegel Grove at the end of September this year. I looked forward to my visit and wanted to know how Rutherford B. Hayes and his family celebrated their Thanksgiving. I learned that for Thanksgiving in 1874, years before Rutherford B. Hayes was elected president and after his terms as Ohio governor, his meal included hominy, or Indian corn, in addition to some present-day traditional items like ham and turkey.

Because I learned that Rutherford B. Hayes ate hominy for one of his Thanksgiving meals, I wanted to learn more about it and was impressed by the history of the food. Rutherford B. Hayes ate hominy for Thanksgiving in 1874, or so it is very likely he did, since his wife Lucy Webb Hayes wrote correspondence to their son detailing the dishes of their family meal. The museum shared an excerpt from the letter that described the meal. In addition to hominy, Lucy Webb Hayes wrote that they ate turkey, ham, stewed tomatoes, fried oysters, browned mashed potatoes, cold slaw, and macaroni and grated cheese. That Thanksgiving, the meal was prepared by a black servant, Winnie Monroe, whose work in the kitchen Lucy Webb Hayes praised in her letter. She also praised Monroe’s assistants by name. I think Lucy Webb Hayes had a close relationship with Monroe. I learned from visiting the museum that Lucy Webb Hayes’ parents freed Monroe’s mother from slavery. Monroe remained dedicated to the Hayes family as she was a servant and caregiver who followed them from Ohio to the White House. Lucy Webb Hayes financed the college education of Monroe’s daughter who also worked for the family.



The dining room at Spiegel Grove appears after an addition was added in 1889 after the death of Lucy Webb Hayes.


The history of hominy interested me. Hominy was an American Indian food and by at least the 1700s it was adopted into the foods of black slaves. It remains a food important to southern cooking, but it also was a common food in the 19th century. It made a part of camp meals for soldiers during the Civil War. I wondered if it was because Rutherford B. Hayes was so proud of his war service that eating hominy at Thanksgiving might have been a special way to solemnly remember his and others’ sacrifices during the Civil War. Rutherford B. Hayes is known to have stayed loyal to the soldiers he led by battling even when others in his Republican Party tried to persuade him to leave the war early to campaign for public office. By the time the war concluded, Rutherford B. Hayes had been wounded in multiple incidents. He went on to serve as a congressman. In many of his Thanksgiving proclamations, either as governor or president, he often mentioned being in peacetime as one of the reasons for Americans to worship and give thanks in a religious sense.

 I wondered if the people in America who ate hominy in the 1800s respected its history having come from American Indians originally. During Rutherford B. Hayes’ time American Indians were assimilated or made to live on reservations apart from their original lands. Our history as a country and that of our ancestors is complicated. On one level, President Rutherford B. Hayes respected that the land designated as reservations strictly belonged to the American Indian tribes and he sought to protect those lands from encroachment. I still view this period as a blemish on our country’s history. Centuries later Thanksgiving in the United States became an important time for a citizen like me to honor the history of American Indians as well as be a time for me to thank God for my blessings in general.



We Tried Civil War Period Recipes at Home

In October Corey and I made a preview to Thanksgiving dinner when we prepared a split turkey breast, green bean casserole, hominy with bacon and collard greens and sweet potato biscuits. The meal was inspired by our trip to Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums and what the Hayes family ate for Thanksgiving in 1874. While I do not know how the hominy was prepared for the family in 1874, I knew that President Rutherford B. Hayes was a Civil War veteran who was proud of his service and cared about other veterans, so I purchased a cookbook with recipes from the Civil War era. The cookbook is titled “The Civil War Kitchen Cookbook: 100 Historic Recipes, Soldier Rations, Campfire Meals, Southern Staples, and Hard-Times Foods from the 1860s” by Clayton Daniels. This cookbook was not sold at the museum store; I searched online to find it after we came home.


We prepared hominy with bacon and collard greens.


In trying two recipes from this cookbook, my favorite was the “Sweet Potato Biscuits” warm out of the oven. I did not prefer the “Kettle Hominy with Bacon” very much; its texture is like dumplings, but its taste did not appeal to me. For modern times, we bought canned hominy found among Mexican foods from the grocery store. Hominy is Indian corn that must be processed to be edible, and so the canned hominy made it much easier to prepare.  We prepared it with bacon to use the recipe as the way it would have been available to Civil War soldiers at camp. Collard greens might not have been available for camp meals, but we added them to our meal after the recipe book suggested adding greens. I was impressed with the number of recipes in the book, and Daniels explains from which parts of the country these recipes originated. The “Sweet Potato Biscuits” were from the South; the recipe uses sweet potatoes in lieu of sugar which was less available in the South during the war. I think the cookbook is worth trying more of its recipes. It is comprehensive in its coverage of meals from people on both sides of the war. I appreciated what this author did to provide recipes for reenactors or history lessons.



We prepared “Sweet Potato Biscuits” using the recipe from “The Civil War Kitchen Cookbook.”



Sources

Boyer, Morgan, docent. House Tour, Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums, 27 Sept. 2026, Spiegel Grove, Fremont, OH 43420.

A special thank-you to our tour guide who shared the history of President Rutherford B. Hayes and his family, including biographical information and the relationships they had.


Daniels, Clayton. “The Civil War Kitchen Cookbook: 100 Historic Recipes, Soldier Rations, Campfire Meals, Southern Staples, and Hard-Times Foods from the 1860s,” 2026.

Two recipes that Corey and I made came from this cookbook, “Sweet Potato Biscuits” and “Kettle Hominy with Bacon.”


Holloway, Joseph. “"What Africa Has Given America": African Continuities in the North American Diaspora.” Africanisms in American Culture, Second Edition, Indiana University Press, 2024. African-American History, online.infobase.com/Auth/Index?aid=6099&itemid=WE01&articleId=658731.

This online excerpt from the book explains hominy was an American Indian food that slaves used in meals as early as the 1700s.


“Lincoln and Thanksgiving.” National Park Service, 27 Nov. 2024, https://www.nps.gov/liho/learn/historyculture/lincoln-and-thanksgiving.htm .

This webpage of the National Park Service provides the context for President Abraham Lincoln’s Thanksgiving proclamation in 1863.



About the Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Library and Museums

Click on the following link to learn more about this site.

https://www.rbhayes.org/